Who Killed Laurel Jean Mitchell?

The small lake community of North Webster had never before – and has not since – seen a crime like the 1975 murder of a local teenager. Even today, with the case still unsolved, the community remembers the case of Laurel Jean Mitchell. Laurel’s father was Richard D. “Dick” Mitchell, a well known public figure in North Webster. He passed away on Jan. 16, 2012. Wilma Mitchell, her mother, operated the North Webster Food Pantry for several years and also passed away last year. They died never knowing what exactly happened to their 17-year-old daughter or why she was sexually assaulted, killed, and her body thrown into the Elkhart River less than 20 miles from their home. Police records from a series of interviews show it was 10 p.m. on Aug. 6, 1975, when Laurel left her job at a restaurant in Epworth Forest and began the walk up Epworth Forest Drive to Adventureland, a one time thriving amusement park. Hours after Laurel’s disappearance, as the daylight broke, her body was found lifeless ...